GA-01514 1998-09-27 relevance B licensed / copyrighted
Rethink on Suharto role in coup (South China Sunday Morning Post, 27 September 1998)
South China Sunday Morning Post, 27 Sep 1998, p.8, Jenny Grant: after Suharto's fall, historians and politicians call for a reassessment of the 1965 coup and killings; the government has dropped compulsory screening of the New Order propaganda film. The article repeats that members of 'the communist women's organisation, Gerwani' mutilated the generals' bodies before dumping them at Halim, while noting that historians (e.g. Hermawan Sulistyo) say Suharto's regime enforced a compulsory version of events and that land-reform conflicts triggered the killings.
South China Sunday Morning Post, 27 Sep 1998, hlm. 8, Jenny Grant: setelah Suharto jatuh, sejarawan dan politisi menyerukan peninjauan ulang kudeta dan pembunuhan 1965; pemerintah menghentikan kewajiban menayangkan film propaganda Orde Baru. Artikel mengulang bahwa anggota 'organisasi perempuan komunis Gerwani' memutilasi jenazah para jenderal sebelum dibuang di Halim, sambil mencatat sejarawan (mis. Hermawan Sulistyo) menyebut rezim Suharto memaksakan versi tunggal dan konflik landreform memicu pembunuhan.
“Members of the rural communist women's organisation, Gerwani, 'then mutilated the men's bodies before they were dumped' at Halim; historian Hermawan Sulistyo says the New Order 'twisted the collective memory by enforcing a compulsory version' of events.”
People
Organisations
Places
Events
Topics
Tags
Details
- Date
- 1998-09-27
- Creator
- South China Sunday Morning Post
- Publication
- South China Sunday Morning Post
- Document type
- newspaper article (newspaper or periodical article/page)
- Language
- English
- Perspective
- Journalism/commentary (post-1998)
- Source role
- primary
- Country
- Hong Kong
- Period
- 1980–1998
- Source archive
- ProQuest Historical Newspapers (International / U.S. collections, Columbia) · source link
- Access
- library-licensed (Columbia University Libraries); personal research copy Library-licensed or subscription copy: show metadata and summary only; link to the source.
- File
- 01 Primary Sources/1.5 Newspapers and Periodicals/International press (1949-2000) - newspaper and magazine articles on Gerwani (ProQuest, Gale)/South China Sunday Morning Post (1998-09-27) - Rethink on Suharto role in coup [ProQuest 1918941619].pdf
- OCR / text
- Fair (0.874) · proof-reading: whole text (Claude, Oct 2026) · translation: not needed
- Collection
- 01 Primary Sources › 1.5 Newspapers and Periodicals › International press (1949-2000) - newspaper and magazine articles on Gerwani (ProQuest, Gale)
- Summary basis
- full text read; OCR largely unreadable
Related items
The Treachery on YouTube: Politics of Memory on New Media in Indonesia (Parahita and Yulianto, 2020)
Journal article by Gilang Desti Parahita and Vissia Ita Yulianto (Archipel 99, 2020, pp. 47-73) on how YouTube reproduces the New Order's 'Pengkhianatan G30S/PKI' as monumental memory while alternative 1965 films circulate far less. Gerwani appears on p. 63: filmmaker Lexy Rambadetta, after meeting former Gerwani membe
shared: Release of the film Pengkhianatan G30S/PKI, Indonesian National Armed Forces, Suharto, Bali
Remembering and Forgetting at Lubang Buaya (Schreiner, 2003)
Klaus Schreiner's 2003 chapter reading the Monumen Pancasila Sakti at Lubang Buaya as a 'site of memory' and founding shrine of the New Order, noting the 1998 end of the annual film broadcast; applies Halbwachs, Nora and trauma theory. Memory-studies framing.
shared: Release of the film Pengkhianatan G30S/PKI, Indonesian National Armed Forces, Suharto, film
Tempo, 1 October 2012: Film, state terror and the nation's wound (Ariel Heryanto)
Ariel Heryanto essay in Tempo (1 Oct 2012) on state terror, propaganda film and the 1965 wound, from Supersemar and the Pengkhianatan G30S/PKI film to post-1998 indie documentaries and The Act of Killing. One passage states Gerwani leaders were detained, raped, tortured and portrayed as immoral mutilators in army press
shared: Release of the film Pengkhianatan G30S/PKI, Suharto, film, Lubang Buaya and sexual slander
Construction of History under the New Order: making the Lubang Buaya narrative (summary, 2010)
Seven-page summary (LIPI journal, 2010) of Djakababa's dissertation arguing 1 Oct 1965 was chaotic and the New Order turned it into a good-versus-evil narrative via trials, the monument, commemoration and the film. Short companion to the full thesis.
shared: Release of the film Pengkhianatan G30S/PKI, Suharto, film, Lubang Buaya and sexual slander
Chaos at Crocodile Hole (The Guardian, 23 May 1998)
The Guardian, 23 May 1998, p.24, Martin Woollacott, 'Chaos at Crocodile Hole': comment on Suharto's fall, arguing it is no triumph and that his legacy of division (military vs Islamists, rich vs poor, ethnic and religious tensions) leaves the country fragile. It opens with the Crocodile Hole (Lubang Buaya) shrine, whos
shared: Fall of Suharto and Reformasi, Indonesian National Armed Forces, Suharto, historiography
Gerry van Klinken's 2001 article mapping the post-Suharto contest over the national past: statist New Order history (film, Lubang Buaya rituals, book bans), versus societal streams including Sulami's 1999 truth-seeking organisation and Pramoedya. Historiographical context.
shared: Fall of Suharto and Reformasi, revisionist reassessment, historiography
The Forgotten Years: Mass Slaughter in Jombang-Kediri 1965-1966 (Sulistyo, 1997)
Hermawan Sulistyo's 1997 Arizona State history PhD, 'The Forgotten Years', studies the 1965-66 killings in Jombang-Kediri, East Java, from interviews and documents, finding no single national pattern and stressing local conflict and military-backed operations. Gerwani appears in passing: its claimed 1.75 million member
shared: Indonesian National Armed Forces, Suharto, Hermawan Sulistyo, East Java
The Guardian (Weekend Guardian), 8 Sept 1990, p.A4, John Gittings, 'The black hole of Bali': long feature on the 1965 massacre (250,000 or more killed), how the killings were organised by the army under Suharto, the Aidit/PKI role, the US list of communists (Martens/Kadane) and US encouragement, survivors ('Tapols') an
shared: Indonesian National Armed Forces, Central Intelligence Agency, Suharto, Central Java